The Future of Hospitals in the Netherlands in 2015
RESEARCH QUESTIONS:
1. Financial structure
- Who is financing (externally)? How structured? Solidarity?
- Influence new insurance system? What in basic insurance and what should be additional insured?
- What is finance structure internally?
- What are the consequences of the integrations (mergers) of health insurance companies...buying power?
- Who pays the costs that are a result of life style induced illness? Where begins own responsibily and risk?
- Involvement government H or L?
- Percentage of GDPspend on healthcare?
2. Demand for hospital care
http://www.kiesbeter.nl/Home/Start.aspx
3. Supply side of hospital care
- Labour market for physicians, nurses
- What is development of technology and influence thereof on hospital care; what are costs involved?
- Care remains labour-intensive? Scarcity of labour? Costs involved?
4. Organization of hospital care
- Public owned vs private owned hospitals?
- Differentiated care (per indication, per type of patient)? Differentiated tariffs?
- Limitations to free market? Currently 'B-segment'
- Emergency care responsibility governments as oposite to elective care? How about 'cherry picking' or cross-subsidizing between DFCs?
- Other suppliers (e.g. private enterprises for diagnostics)?
- What are the consequences of the integrations (fusions) of hospitals with other hospitals and homes for the elderly (less and bigger hospitals, less choice where to go etc.)??
- In that matter: what will happen with prices when the free market for hospital care changes because of the integration of market parties
- Involvement government H or L?
5. Ethical debate
- At the the moment there is a (sort of) general opinion that we have to apply every possible technical solution to cure people, even when this is very expensive. This opinion will probably not hold because of rapid technical developments. What will happen? - change in public opinion?
- Role of QUALITY? A life year added in fair quality in the western world is allowed to cost appr. € 18.000
- Technological developments in genomics and biotechnology will imply a shift from cure to prevention - this implies another type of healthcare and a significant decrease in the number of hospital bed days. Uncertainty is what comes out of the ethical debate.
6. Other external factors
- MRSA ?
- Birdflu?
- Othere pandemia?
BACKGROUND:
Medical cost and demand in healthcare are swelling. An intensifying dissatisfaction among patients, government officials, insurers, employers, clinicians and healthcare executives is noticeable. The soaring prices paid to treat the growing volumes of demanding, aging patients are prompting payers to search for more efficient ways of treatment and care. Next to that the government in Holland has introduced the new healthcare payment system with a new insurance system and diagnosis treatment combinations. The main aim of this transition is the development from a budget oriented system to a more market oriented health care system. The belief is that a market oriented system will create more incentives for efficiency, quality and innovation. Many hospitals in the Netherlands have to withstand those forces and the severe capital crunch they create. As many of our group have a certain affinity with the healthcare sector (from different angles: Insurer, pharmaceutical, hospital and client perspective) we formulated the following scenario definition. Scenario definition: ‘The future of hospitals in the Netherlands in 2020’ Main driving forces: There are a few driving forces (PWC, 1999) which create the severe capital crunch the hospitals in The Netherlands are getting in to.
- The impact of E-health on the healthcare business;
- E-health will be used for transactions between suppliers, other providers, payers, regulators and patients
- E-health will be used for information for patients and healthcare workers and will be used as a marketing and branding tool for the hospitals;
- E-health will be used for interaction between with providers and intermediaries
The shift from cure to prevention due to new technologies like genomics and biotech advances
- Genomics will open markets for diagnostic testing, preventive medicine, follow up treatments and even support services such as lifestyle counselling
- Life sciences and information technology will fuse into biotechnical discoveries in the decade ahead, restrained only by the financial purse strings of government agencies (like NWO), private foundations, pharmaceutical companies and informal investors
- The impact of the new healthcare financing system in the Netherlands
- The new (privatized) healthcare system will have it’s impact on the amount of services, the patients, the healthcare insurers, the intermediaries, the suppliers like pharmaceutical companies and the hospitals
- The impact of the new market oriented financing system with the diagnosis treatment combinations
- Finally a driver we want to include in our scenario’s is the future scarcity of labor in the Netherlands
- The aging population will have it’s impact on the health care sector. It will be growing. At this moment about 300.000 people are working in the health care sector. But will there be the estimated necessary 600.000 workers in the future? Methodology: So far, we have identified four plausible drivers. In the further development of our project we will have to ‘dig into the facts’. We will do this by a thourough literature study. Gather the facts and figures and substantiate on our findings this far. Secondly, our intention is to have some in-depth interviews with some opinion leaders in the field of hospital care, farmaceutics and insurance. We wil speak with them about their expectations, and will try to verify our findings. These two angles (literature study and interviews) will be our solid academical ground in defining our scenario’s and the strategic possibilities as a result of the scenario’s we will try to define for this project.
References:
- PricewaterhouseCoopers Healthcast 2010 – smaller world, bigger expectations, 1999
- PricewaterhouseCoopers HealtCast Tactics: A blueprint for the future, 2002
DRIVING FORCES
- Increasing privatisation of hospitals
- Increase in health care costs
- Technology developmentleading to new diagnostic and treatment options
- The growing population of overweight people
- Aging population
- Increasing Neglect of the Elderly
- Increase in Stress of Adult Workers in The Netherlands
- Increasing Empowerment of Consumers in Healthcare System
- Liberalization of the Dutch health care market
- the rise of ethics in the Netherlands
- Patient empowerment
- Decreased role of general practitioner as 'gatekeeper'for hospital care
- Future shortage in healthcare workers effects availability hospital care negatively
- Providers will integrate foreward, setting up own clinics
CLUSTERED DRIVING FORCES
- Technology (genomics, biotechnology, E-health, medical technology)
- Free-market mechanisms
- Changing patient profiles (aging population, empowered patients, more morbidity and lifestyle)
- Ethical debate (to what extent does this inhibit innovation)
DRAFT SCENARIO GRID
File:Tweebijtweetje def.jpg
SCENARIO'S/SHORT STORIES (still WIP)
1.The evil empire / A clock work orange
Under the influence of for profit insurers hospital care become desintegrated production lines. This fragmentation is financially driven by all stakeholders: insurers, care providers and patients. People act selfish and short term wins rule. Ethical arguments are found irrelevant in discussing the use of new technology. Specialists / doctors discover liberalization and make scandalous amounts of money with helping only the people who pay extra, result: with bad hospital- an insurer management there is no countervailing power for doctors. As a result of power in the production lines and bad negotiating power of insurance companies, the “B-DBC’s” (free prices) lead to an increase price exceeding inflation. Insurance companies introduce all kinds of new health packages that people cannot resist (2007). This translates into increased insurance premium for patients in 2008. Patients have no choice but to pay health insurance premiums, result: poverty and bad publicity. Cost of health care (and hospital care) in the Netherlands explodes to more than 15% of GDP in 2011. At the end (2013), the system crashes. Dutch parliament does a parliamentary inquiry on the (un-)equal access to hospital care and bad negotiation of insurance companies, conclusion: government has to intervene in free market.Government introduces salary cap hospital CEO’s, Budgeting is re-introduced in 2015
2.Kaiser Social
After the crash of the Dutch insurance system in 2007 (only 1.5.year after introduction) a visionary not for profit HMO took the initiative to regionally organize insureres, first line health care, home care, hospital care. This system is driven by societal responsibility. Patient movement and government are happy with these developments.
Integrated care is one of the cornerstones of the new health care system. With Kaiser Social, consumers don't just buy insurance. For a fixed monthly fee, they gain easy access to an organized system that provides integrated preventive, routine, emergency, and hospital care
There is an integrated health delivery system, which means that the entire scope of care for the community is provided and coordinated, including:
- preventive care
- well-baby and prenatal care
- immunizations
- emergency care
- screening diagnostics
- hospital and medical services
- pharmacy services
New technologies (broadband, long distance observation and advice, telemonitoring, day-treatment) enable people to stay home longer and earlier; resulting in less inpatient care in hospitals.The system flourishes by depending much on social interaction and costs are driven down.
Futher keyword(s): vertical integration
3.European competition
The Dutch healthcare is tsunamied away by the collaps of the isurance system, EU ruling (Decker-Kohl, Smits-Peereboom), NMA limits on (national) merger movement among hospitals and by scarcity of (qualified) labor. No personnel and lots of vacancies in caring profession. As patient interest is not served, new initiatives fill the vacuum. The new libaralized model uses economies of scale and competition does not take place on a local but on EU scope. Other countries provide well arranged healthcare; international investors (even non EU e.g. US, Arab and Russian)take over hospitals and organize specialized hospitals spread over the EU. EU conglomerates can insure Dutch patients at attractive rates. For a total hip a patient travels to Turkey, for a coronairy bypass Romania is the place to be. Here highly qualified staff is available or is recruited in other countries. Less interference of some governments in the ethical debate enable further growth of biotechnology and genomics in these countries, enabling a further preferred position in the healthcare market.
Further keywords: analogy electricity-market; undertaking example (‘dig the American way’)
SOURCES OF INFORMATION
- Healthcast 2010: Smaller world, Bigger Expectations. PWC. November 1999. [1]
- Healthcast Tactics: A Blueprint for the future. PWC. May 2002. [2]
- Stress, satisfaction and burnout among Dutch medical specialists. Mechteld R.M. Visser, Ellen M.A. Smets, Frans J. Oort, Hanneke C.J.M. de Haes
- Market in Need of Products That Address Key Concerns of Growing Patient Population and Rising Healthcare Costs; Developing New and Innovative Technologies is the Way Forward. September 6, 2005. PR Newswire Association LLC.
- Specialty Cardiac Hospitals Treat Less Severely Ill Patients Than Non-Specialty Hospitals . July 12, 2005 Tuesday 12:00 PM GMT. Business Wire, Inc
- SER (1999) Gezondheidszorg in het licht van de toekomstige vergrijzing, The Hague: SER
- Rol en positie van medisch specialisten 2005; OCM/ Dr. A.C.J.M. Olsthoorn, September 2005
- www.minvwsnl
- www.zorgaanzet.nl
- www.cbz.nl
- www.ctg-zaio.nl
INTERVIEWS
- Partners PWC
- Director Achmea Healthcare
- Professor of Neurology: routine (peripheral) care vs. highly specialized (university) care will have significant impact on financing hospital care: new structure is needed
- Departmental head Dutch Association of hospitals: hospitals will end up in a hybrid model (partly liberalized market, partly regulated) that will jeopardize continuity; a drastic change in finance structure is needed
- Director regional Patient Organization South West of the Netherlands
- secretary of the board of Erasmus MC